Distant Island of Nice Nicobar Threatened by Container Terminal

In 1667 a Swedish sailor reported that on his travels within the Far East he’d landed on the island of Nice Nicobar, whose inhabitants had “a tail hanging like a cat’s tail, but bald, and they could toss it however they liked, like a cat does.” He’d evidently encountered the Shompen, who tie a strip of bark across the waist, letting its finish dangle behind them. Greater than a century later this fanciful account led Scottish thinker Lord Monboddo to postulate that the islanders had been the frequent ancestors of people and orangutans (each of which had misplaced their tails).

Science has since realized extra about evolution, however the Shompen stay virtually as enigmatic as ever. Numbering anyplace between 200 and 400, these hunters, gatherers and shifting cultivators largely stay within the steep, forested inside of Nice Nicobar and shun outsiders. Solely fragments of their language, tradition and beliefs have been deciphered by teachers. This previous April seven Shompen males who had emerged from the forest had been persuaded to forged ballots in India’s common elections—though they will have little concept what a nation of 1.4 billion folks is, not to mention what elections are. Nor might they comprehend the hazard they’re in. As 39 students warned in February, the Shompen are dealing with “a death sentence” that’s “tantamount to the international crime of genocide.”

The Indian authorities, which inherited Nice Nicobar Island from British colonizers, is about to construct a large transshipment terminal there. Described as a new Hong Kong, the $9-billion free-trade zone is to incorporate a port with an eventual capability to deal with 16 million cargo containers a yr, a city for 350,000 folks resettled from mainland India, ancillary industries, an influence plant and a global airport for use by 4,000 peak-hour passengers.

On supporting science journalism

Should you’re having fun with this text, think about supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By buying a subscription you’re serving to to make sure the way forward for impactful tales concerning the discoveries and concepts shaping our world immediately.

The undertaking will fell near 1,000,000 primeval rainforest bushes in its preliminary part alone and in the end unfold over 244 sq. kilometers—practically a fifth of Nice Nicobar. It’s not solely the Shompen who will probably be devastated. The island can also be house to the Nice Nicobarese, an Indigenous individuals who lived primarily alongside the southern and western coast till the huge tsunami of 2004 washed most of them away. The survivors had been evacuated to the jap coast, the place they reunited with compatriots who returned from finding out or visiting elsewhere. The Nice Nicobarese have lengthy pleaded with the Indian authorities to be allowed to return to their ancestral lands. However these are to be subsumed by amenities related to the advanced.

Simply as worrisome, this emerald drop in an ink-blue ocean, probably the most pristine locations left on Earth, is “globally irreplaceable from a biodiversity conservation viewpoint,” in keeping with the Alliance for Zero Extinction. The silver-sand seaside edging Galathea Bay, on the southern finish of Nice Nicobar, for instance, is the Northern Indian Ocean’s largest nesting website for endangered Leatherback sea turtles, a species so venerable that it’s shared Earth not solely with us but in addition with the dinosaurs. This beautiful bay, which incorporates not less than 117 species of corals, is to be dredged and developed into the container terminal, a seawall virtually totally blocking its entrance—a loss of life entice for marine animals.

Nice Nicobar is a additionally a UNESCO biosphere reserve and a part of the Sundaland biodiversity hotspot, a area whose extraordinary biodiversity impressed the evolution concept of Alfred Russel Wallace, Charles Darwin’s nice rival. Of the greater than 2,500 species of fauna and flora so far documented on the island, 17 p.c are endemic—discovered solely on Nice Nicobar or typically additionally on the opposite, far smaller, islands of the Nicobar archipelago.

Environmentalists have warned that the clear-cutting, blasting, dredging, development, dumping of particles, ship site visitors, air pollution of a number of varieties and the large inflow of outsiders with their animals and germs will devastate the Indigenous folks and the creatures who stay on and round Nice Nicobar. Irrespective of: after Prime Minister Narendra Modi introduced the undertaking in August 2020, his authorities shepherded it previous all regulatory and authorized hurdles, in such haste that it repeatedly tripped over itself.

In January 2021, as an illustration, India’s minister of surroundings, forest and local weather change launched a doc itemizing Galathea Bay among the many most necessary marine turtle habitats in India—apparently unaware {that a} wildlife board, which he additionally headed, had days earlier revoked the bay’s protected standing. All that occurred lengthy earlier than a non-public agency with no expertise in conservation printed an omission-ridden draft of an environmental affect evaluation (EIA) in December 2021. Amongst different issues, the EIA failed to say all however two of the 15 species of dolphins and whales noticed in waters close to Nice Nicobar.

The sequence of occasions signifies that the Modi authorities chosen Galathea Bay because the undertaking website without any consideration of the way it would possibly have an effect on both Indigenous folks or wildlife. Nor does it appear eager to know the total affect. Authorities-affiliated scientists appear to nonetheless have entry to Nice Nicobar, however for impartial researchers, acquiring permits to work on the island has change into like “getting a ticket to the moon,” one observer says. Earlier this yr a senior official entrusted with defending Indigenous rights blasted the undertaking’s critics as being a part of “an international conspiracy.”

I’m no conspirator; I’m simply in love with this a part of the world. Twenty years in the past I wrote a guide concerning the hunter-gatherers of the Andaman archipelago, which lies north of the Nicobar Islands. (A couple of of the Andaman islanders enforced their voluntary isolation, important for his or her survival, by killing an American missionary in 2018.) Nice Nicobar has at all times been much less accessible than the Andamans, besides to Indian authorities officers and former protection personnel and their households, who had been granted land parcels round Campbell Bay on the east coast, primarily within the Nineteen Seventies. The Indian navy constructed an air station close to the bay in 2012.

I’ve by no means visited the Nicobars. However through the years, as I heard tales of the elusive Shompen and of the island’s unusual birds and animals, I got here to consider Nice Nicobar as a magical world moderately like Pandora of the Avatar films—full with Indigenous peoples, luminous mushrooms, majestic bushes 1000’s of years previous, and mysterious creatures of the forest, shoreline and deep. To me, the “development” deliberate for this island is as a lot of a desecration because the invasion of Pandora.

The Andaman and Nicobar island chains are peaks of an undersea mountain vary scraped off the ocean flooring over hundreds of thousands of years because the Indian geological plate pushes beneath the Eurasian. As small inexperienced havens in an enormous ocean, they’re already a marine and aerial hub—with Nice Nicobar being notably important.

Migratory birds utilizing two nice flyways, the Central Asian and the East Asian-Australasian, throng the island’s shores and wetlands. And monitoring by ecologist Kartik Shanker and his crew signifies that yearly 1000’s of Leatherback hatchlings journey from seashores on the Andaman and Nicobar Islands throughout the Indian Ocean, both 10,000 kilometers east to Madagascar and Mozambique or west to Indonesia and Australia. A long time later, as adults weighing as much as a metric ton, the Leatherbacks return to their natal seashores to put their very own eggs. Human ecologist Manish Chandi has described as “supernatural” the spectacle of those leviathans hauling themselves out of the ocean on a winter night time to proceed a cycle of life honed over hundreds of thousands of years.

Nice Nicobar’s surrounding waters have been solely partially explored by naturalists. They include a few of the most pristine coral reefs on the earth, with 273 documented species of stony corals, amongst which stay, alongside the jap coast alone, 256 species of fish. The coral reefs, sea grass beds, and craggy undersea ridges and valleys, sloping into inky depths on both facet of the island chain, shelter and nourish “an incredible diversity” of marine mammals, says marine biologist Mahi Mankeshwar. Other than the dugong, a manatee sibling and a distant relative of elephants, these embody the Indo-Pacific bottlenose, Spinner, Pantropical Noticed, Risso’s and Fraser’s dolphins, orcas and false killer whales, Omura’s whales and the enigmatic sperm whale.

Virtually nothing is understood concerning the area’s sperm whales. However in different elements of the world, close-knit pods of feminine sperm whales and their offspring stay primarily in tropical waters, speaking by way of clicks so structurally advanced as to counsel a language. Completely different pods might even have totally different dialects. Younger males go away their maternal pods to kind “bachelor schools,” progressively migrating towards the poles and turning into extra solitary. As adults, they roam freezing polar waters or journey 1000’s of kilometers to tropical seas to hunt females, spreading their genes across the globe.

What’s going to the transshipment undertaking do to aerial and marine guests to Nice Nicobar and its surrounding seas? Conservationists’ detailed critique of the EIA gives a clue. The star of the East Asian-Australasian flyway, the Bar-tailed Godwit, can fly nonstop for greater than 13,000 kilometers. However most migratory birds want frequent stops for nourishment, and, in keeping with ornithologist Shashank Dalvi, coastal improvement in China has already destroyed many feeding grounds. Some species might not survive the lack of one more hyperlink on this very important chain or the doubtless oil spills.

Shanker holds that Leatherback turtles are savvy sufficient to keep away from Galathea Bay in the event that they sense disturbances there. That will spare most of them from collisions with ships, however they’d lose an idyllic nesting seaside, locations which might be more and more laborious to return by. The species is already endangered by a number of different threats, resembling drowning in fishing nets and local weather change.

Coral reefs in Galathea Bay, house to myriads of bizarre creatures, will probably be destroyed, and people for kilometers round will probably be smothered by silt or harmed by turbidity and water air pollution. Bottlenose dolphins, typically seen within the bay, and Omura’s whales—two species that stay in coastal waters—will lose their habitats. As for the opposite species of dolphins and whales in surrounding seas, described as “one of the last reserves of undisturbed marine mammal populations in the world,” their survival will probably be threatened by, to call just some components, collisions with ships, undersea noise and oil spills.

One would assume the aerial and marine guests to Nice Nicobar and its shores would alone preclude main improvement. However the creatures and vegetation native to the island, most of which developed in isolation to yield a cornucopia of distinctive species, are simply as intriguing—and so diversified that whole books have been dedicated to describing them.

Nice Nicobar’s endemic mammals embody characters such because the Nicobar Lengthy-tailed Macaque. Round 1900 these monkeys encountered a white explorer and aggravated him by throwing their arms on their face with “an expression of absolute horror,” amongst different gestures “indicative of shocked and outraged feelings.” Masters of instrument use, these primates extract fibers from leaves to floss their enamel, scratch their backs with twigs and break open coconuts with rocks. So ingenious are they that, when raiding settlers’ farms and orchards (which, to be truthful, occupy land cleared of pandanus groves that the macaques used to feed on), they keep away from consideration by breaking apart into small teams, every of which snacks discreetly on a unique kind of fruit or vegetable.

Then there are Nicobar Treeshrews, sentinels of the forest that, within the phrases of zoologist Louise Emmons, “border on the neurotic,” squeaking maddeningly each time they spot an intruder—and outing naturalists making an attempt to cover in painstakingly camouflaged hideouts. So skittish are they that, fearing a predator would possibly observe them to their nest, they feed their younger for just a few minutes each two or three days.

One other endemic mammal, the Nicobar Flying Fox, is without doubt one of the world’s solely two identified species of Pteropus fruit bats that’s solitary in its roosting habits. In response to a Nice Nicobarese legend, an previous girl was feeling chilly and sick, so somebody supplied her a blanket. Finally she received higher and the climate received hotter, however by then the blanket was caught to her again. Feeling unattractive in it, she started to enterprise out solely at night time, when nobody else might see her. To today, she roams the forest each night time as a bat and protects it.

Nice Nicobar can also be labeled as an necessary chook space in classes A1, “known or thought regularly to hold significant numbers of a globally threatened species,” and A2, “known or thought to hold a significant population of at least two range-restricted species.” Among the many birds, the Nice Nicobar Serpent Eagle (the world’s smallest eagle), the Nicobar Jungle Flycatcher, the Nicobar Scops Owl and the Nicobar Parakeet stay solely on Nice Nicobar or its small sibling, Little Nicobar. The iridescent Nicobar pigeon, a zoo favourite, is a relative of the dodo.

The idiosyncratic Nicobar Megapode lives as mating {couples} in forests close to the coast, constructing mounds of sand, corals and plant particles to put their eggs in. The rotting vegetation supplies heat to incubate the eggs; the feminine periodically checks the temperature along with her toes to verify it’s optimum. As soon as the chicks have dug their method out of the mound, the couple spruces it up for the subsequent brood. No less than 50 of the 95 everlasting nesting websites will probably be subsumed by the transshipment advanced.

I received’t begin with the freshwater fish, reptiles, amphibians, bugs and different arthropods and vegetation which might be distinctive to Nice Nicobar—the record is just too lengthy. One exception to notice is that, curiously for a tropical island, Nice Nicobar has no toxic snakes. (However there’s a kind of reticulated python, which the Shompen eat.) One other is that the world’s largest land crab lives right here, too; it climbs coconut bushes, nips off coconuts, retrieves them on the bottom and cracks them open to eat the white flesh. And the Andaman water monitor by some means discovered its method right here—however skipped the northern and central Nicobar islands.

Many of those creatures might be exterminated by the undertaking. Certainly one of its most harmful features is the large inflow of outsiders. On the Andaman Islands, for instance, newcomers cleared forests for settlement, lowering humidity and precipitation and inflicting water shortages which have additionally plagued them. Together with them got here animals like canines and cats that prey on weak creatures like sea turtles and nesting birds. One other hazard is illness transmission: avian cholera killed many home fowl within the Campbell Bay settlement in 1997, birdwatcher Uday Mondal famous in an article, and a few megapodes additionally appeared to be affected. However there isn’t any report of how the megapodes fared.

A associated drawback is rubbish. Dumping from the Campbell Bay settlement, with its inhabitants of about 6,000 (as measured in 2011), is already inflicting drawbacks for locals. Having misplaced their former feeding grounds to urbanization, and with a few of the settlers capturing, poisoning or electrocuting them to discourage raids on plantations, the macaques typically feed on trash; they might get sick. The EIA describes the macaques as a “menace.” If that’s how the designated protectors of wildlife see these primates, which the Worldwide Union for Conservation of Nature classifies as “vulnerable,” the probabilities of the Nicobar long-tailed macaque surviving alongside a whole bunch of 1000’s of settlers is slim.

In sum, the creatures that may will flee to the mountains, the place they may displace others; these that may’t will die. With its inside forests and streams nonetheless largely unexplored, likelihood is this wildlife paradise has many treasures that might be destroyed earlier than they’re documented. Each zoological or botanical expedition finds new species, together with, this previous January, an endemic flowering plant.

“We’ve barely scratched the surface,” Chandi says.

Of all Nice Nicobar’s inhabitants, essentially the most enigmatic could also be our fellow people, the Shompen. Steep hills, dense jungles and malaria have defeated most adventurers who’ve sought to go to their inside settlements. Nonetheless, the tales these vacationers introduced again, in addition to accounts collected with the assistance of the Nice Nicobarese, supply a tough sense of how the Shompen stay.

They spear crocodiles, fish, and different animals and collect fruit and different edibles. Curiously (and in contrast to the Andaman islanders), the Shompen don’t use bows and arrows. Solely partly nomadic, they construct huts on platforms, normally close to pandanus groves, which in flip are discovered close to streams. They have an inclination to the groves and, in small patches, domesticate tubers and greens.

A couple of Shompen males, presumably from totally different teams throughout the forest, historically visited the coastal Nice Nicobarese villages to trade jungle produce resembling cane and honey for iron instruments, tobacco, fabric and different items. The coast dwellers, in flip, acknowledged Shompen guardianship of the jungle by, for instance, in search of their permission earlier than chopping a tree there, anthropologist Ajay Saini has famous.

A long time again, when the Indian authorities cleared area for settlers close to Campbell Bay, it minimize down pandanus groves that the Shompen had nurtured and displaced a number of of their hamlets. These days the authorities supply the shifting cultivators rations of rice and lentils, which, once more, a handful of males arrive to gather. However the Shompen refuse to permit outsiders to observe them again into the jungle. Sooner or later, “they stop and stay put until we move away, or they just pack up their belongings and disappear” into the forest, Chandi relates.

So impenetrable is the terrain that every Shompen band, consisting of a handful of households, is remoted sufficient to own its personal dialect. Linguist George van Driem reviewed compilations of Shompen phrases to conclude that their language, like these of the Nicobarese, belongs to the Mon-Khmer department of the Austroasiatic household, spoken primarily in Vietnam and Cambodia. Genetic research assist this view, whereas including element. They present that the Shompen and the Nicobarese descend from the identical founding inhabitants originating in Southeast Asia. Not like the Nicobarese, nevertheless, the Shompen have been genetically remoted for about 14,000 years, apart from an inflow of Y chromosomes—that’s, male DNA—about 3,000 years in the past.

Genes say little about geography, geneticist T. Sitalaximi cautions, however it appears affordable to deduce that the Shompen’s ancestors had been remoted since arriving on Nice Nicobar about 14,000 years in the past. The boys who merged with them 3,000 years in the past had been carefully associated to the Indigenous Aeta of the Philippines and the Semang and Orang Asli of Malaysia, in keeping with Sitalaximi—peoples whom earlier students had mistakenly, it appears, linked with the Andamanese.

Though the Shompen are understandably cautious of outsiders, the Nicobarese have historically welcomed them. Earlier than the 2004 tsunami, they lived in peaceable beachside villages, crafting canoes to journey to close by islands and to fish within the coral reefs. They raised pigs, grew greens and nurtured coconut groves. Historic seafarers touring alongside commerce routes between China and India, and even as far west because the Roman Empire, routinely stopped on the Nicobar Islands to top off with coconuts and different provides.

Round 1292 Marco Polo landed on one of many islands, presumably Nice Nicobar, and later reported that the folks possessed magnificent lengths of coloured silk, which they purchased from passing retailers. They didn’t use the cloths to adorn themselves—they had been bare—however stored the sashes “hung over rails in their houses as a token of wealth and magnificence.” Their island was munificent: its “noble trees of great worth” included “red sandal, coconuts (which among us are called Pharoah’s nuts), apples of paradise, cloves, brazil, and many other good trees.”

I’ve by no means visited the Nicobars, however I, too, have been graced by Nicobarese hospitality. One blistering afternoon in Might 1998, I used to be coming back from a go to to a beachside settlement of Onge, the Indigenous folks of Little Andaman Island. The trail was sandy, so I stored falling off my man-sized rented bicycle; the rainforest’s cover bushes had been felled by a government-owned company, so the solar blazed down; and my water provide had run out. I used to be totally drained by the point I dragged my bike right into a Nicobarese village on the best way again. A younger girl standing by one of many elevated huts beckoned to me; with a single stroke, she sliced open a coconut and supplied it. “I drank gratefully of the cool water, sugar and salt,” I wrote in my guide—all that I wanted to be on my method.

On December 26, 2004, when the tsunami hit, it washed away all however 9 of the Nice Nicobarese who had been dwelling on the western coast. Among the many survivors had been Mathias, his girlfriend and his brother, who had been in a canoe at sea, rowing again house after having spent Christmas night time partying at one other village. Thrown onto the island by the waves, they discovered every thing destroyed. Wretched and hungry, they trekked uphill to the closest Shompen settlement, which was unscathed. The forest dwellers gave the brothers a knife and a pair of fire-making sticks. Over the subsequent week, the trio met up with six different survivors. The implements gifted by the Shompen enabled the 5 males and 4 girls to carry out for 35 days on turtle eggs and wild boar till Chandi and others arrived in quest of survivors.

Mathias now serves as an interpreter, translating between Hindi and Shompen. It was by way of him that anthropologist Vishvajit Pandya requested a Shompen man what he thought of improvement. “If you must cut the jungle, cut it along the coast. Do not come near our hills,” the person replied forcefully. “Do not climb our hills.”

However the energy plant and airport the Indian authorities plans to assemble will devour two or three Shompen hamlets close to the Galathea River, which drains into its namesake bay, in addition to two wetlands teeming with waterbirds and saltwater crocodiles, the place the Shompen hunt and forage. The displaced bands will probably be pressured to maneuver upstream, sparking competitors for assets and battle with different Shompen teams, Chandi worries. The effluents from the facility plant will most probably poison the encircling soil and the river, the place the Shompen fish and acquire consuming water.

The forest dwellers may also, and inevitably, encounter development employees and different outsiders, most likely with dire penalties. Sexual violence dedicated by settlers has been a significant issue on the Andamans and will change into one on the Nicobars as properly. Worse, having lived largely in isolation, the Shompen have little immunity to the illnesses that thrive within the exterior world and might be devastated by epidemics, as occurred with the Andaman islanders. No matter microbe killed practically 100 Shompen within the Eighties of diarrhea most likely originated with the Campbell Bay settlement; extra epidemics are inevitable.

The Nice Nicobarese are much less inclined to infections however endure from a mess of illnesses, resembling coronary heart illness and diabetes, due to altered food regimen and way of life since having been evacuated to Campbell Bay. They’ve lengthy pleaded with authorities to be allowed to return to their former villages. However this part of the southeastern coast is earmarked for tourism and different amenities. “We feel helpless and abandoned and are extremely anxious about our future,” the tribal council wrote to the chief administrator of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands in August 2022.

After information of the Nice Nicobar undertaking broke, Indian civil society launched a passionate and deeply knowledgeable marketing campaign to save lots of the island. Partly in response to its considerations and to satisfy regulatory necessities, the Indian authorities has introduced mitigation measures that vary from the ridiculous to the outrageous. The injury to Nice Nicobar’s millions-year-old rainforest is to be compensated for by afforestation on dry hills of western India, which has a totally totally different ecology and can do nothing to save lots of the island’s species. And no matter Shompen territory survives is to be protected against poachers by erecting a “state of [the] art Geo fencing solution equipped with Optical/Thermal cameras, Satellite Phones, Drones”—a militarized border that may terrorize the Indigenous folks into staying away from their very own areas.

Yet one more response is to arrange new wildlife sanctuaries on three small islands off the northern coast of Nice Nicobar. Which may look like a good suggestion—however the satan is within the particulars. Meroe Island is to be a coral sanctuary, though its coral range is unknown. Menchal Island is now a megapode sanctuary, however it has two pairs of megapodes at most and can’t compensate for the lack of Nice Nicobar’s megapode inhabitants. Three seashores on Little Nicobar will probably be a Leatherback sanctuary. Leatherbacks already nest on just a few of Little Andaman’s seashores—that are too small to host the roughly 1,000 females that will probably be displaced from Galathea.

Bizarrely, these three islands will now be off-limits to the Nice and Little Nicobarese, who’ve historically used and guarded them. “Our customs and practices have ensured the integrity of all life on these islands,” they protested in a letter to Indian authorities. Menchal, as an illustration, is guarded by a spirit named Pingaeyak, and Meroe is cared for by a group elder. Equally, a looking taboo protects dugongs close to the seagrass beds to the north of Nice Nicobar, the place the extremely endangered mammals feed. “That’s why the dugongs still thrive there,” Chandi says.

Given the Modi authorities’s monitor report, the disregard for the surroundings and Indigenous rights implicit on this huge undertaking is no surprise. What’s outstanding is its impracticality. Take the matter of geology. Scientist and journalist Pankaj Sekhsaria has identified that the 9.1-magnitude earthquake of 2004 sank the southern tip of Nice Nicobar by round 4 meters. Even and not using a tsunami, one other main earthquake on this very lively fault might destroy the township and kill a whole bunch of individuals.

Former military officer and senior administrator M. G. Devasahayam has additional argued {that a} container terminal on Nice Nicobar is “neither economically viable nor financially feasible.” The large development price, most of which the Indian taxpayer is predicted to bear, will take not less than 50 years to repay as a result of the container terminal, which has no hinterland to soak up or export items, will battle to attract site visitors away from established ports resembling Colombo. (And that’s assuming local weather change hasn’t carried out away with the worldwide delivery business by 2074.) India’s delivery ministry, which revealingly advertises the undertaking as a as soon as in “a lifetime opportunity for investors to reap gold,” had introduced that, ought to the Modi-led Hindu nationalist alliance win the elections—which it has—the ministry would invite bids for the advanced by July and start development by the top of the yr.

I’ve listed, as objectively as I can, many the reason why this isn’t a good suggestion. I can even level out that the World Security Web, a blueprint to “solve the twin crises of biodiversity loss and climate change,” lists the southern finish of Nice Nicobar, together with Galathea Bay, among the many areas requiring safety. I can observe that six out of 9 planetary boundaries have already been crossed, that tropical rainforests retailer humungous portions of carbon, that warmth waves aggravated by local weather change have already killed a whole bunch of individuals this yr, that deforestation can unfold novel viruses that most individuals don’t have any immunity to, or that nobody is aware of simply when biodiversity loss will attain a tipping level in order that your entire net of life unravels.

I can rage: with birds and monkeys falling useless from bushes, fish floating up within the hundreds of thousands, forests burning and corals bleaching due to overheated summers—how does it make sense to willfully destroy rainforest and reefs and mangroves and seashores with their myriad irreplaceable creatures? Or the uncommon cultures through which folks know how one can stay on this world with love for different beings moderately than contempt?

In reality, maybe I care about this island, which I’ve by no means seen and doubtless won’t ever see, as a result of it jogs my memory that dwelling on this Earth, so battered and but nonetheless so stunning, so stuffed with thriller and magic, is a privilege. That we have to maintain onto this magic, as a result of with out it life will probably be just a bit bit much less price dwelling.